Next new Striker

Our CBs are not capable of playing in a back 4 part from T.Silva and it's still not clear if he's going to stay or not. Rudiger and Christensen are much more unreliable in a back 4 formation and Zouma can be insecure with the ball. If you ask me a new CB is a must if we ever want to switch to a 4-2-3-1 or 4-3-3, Chilwell/Alonso and James/Azpi can do the role for 1 more season but if T.Silva leaves in the summer we won't be able to play those formations and get away with it.
That's something I totally agree with for once 😄

I'm not even sure about Thiago as I remember myself seeing him in the back four at PSG two years ago and thought he was rather "finished" for top level. At least to play that day in day out. Also agreed about Rüdiger and Christensen and Zouma. If Thiago isn't staying (probably would leave after a CL win, but no idea) I thought about Boateng who played with a back 4 at Bayern and was their supreme defender this season. Not sure, maybe he could work with Zouma or Rüdiger but that's quite a gamble.

Agreed about Chilwell and the rest as well - although I personally think that the back-ups wouldn't be half as good / usefull in those formations as those exact same players are in our current system. Especially since Chilwell really found his place (and I expect him to get even better there next season).

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Plays left wing/left forward most games. At Leipzig he played off poulson mostly, so im suggesting he plays a similar role but off Havertz or Weghorst.  Not necessarily a winger, but inside forward.
Leipzig played 352/343 similar to how we play right now. 

We played Werner as  LF/LW in basic 4231 and 433 under lamp and it didn't work. You have to play something closer to 442 with werner. 

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Our CBs are not capable of playing in a back 4 part from T.Silva and it's still not clear if he's going to stay or not. Rudiger and Christensen are much more unreliable in a back 4 formation and Zouma can be insecure with the ball. If you ask me a new CB is a must if we ever want to switch to a 4-2-3-1 or 4-3-3, Chilwell/Alonso and James/Azpi can do the role for 1 more season but if T.Silva leaves in the summer we won't be able to play those formations and get away with it.
In back 4, CB will be a slight problem but under Lamp it was our attacker and midfielder that were more problematic defensively. 

 
I love the look of Adam Hložek at Sparta Prague, still very raw and only 18 but he looks fantastic at controlling the front line and does amazing work in bringing other attackers into play. Anyone who manages to pick him up will have an amazing talent on their hands. Decent numbers this season too albeit in the Czech league. 

 
In back 4, CB will be a slight problem but under Lamp it was our attacker and midfielder that were more problematic defensively. 
Our defense was beaten far too many times due to poor defending in the past season, even under Sarri we couldn't deal with simple crosses at times. That is all the fault of the defense, ours wasn't good enough.

An attacker can take a lot of attention and remove the pressure but you can't shield your defense for a full game. Take all big teams and it's basically us and Conte's team that plays with a back 3 on a regular basis, this is not a coincidence. We need better defenders in order to be able to change to a 4-2-3-1 or 4-3-3 and get a good result from it, right now with the players we have it's just too risky. Conte was very defensive and allowed the opposition to have possession, Sarri was very possession based with no risk passes in order to minimize the threat of our defense getting exposed and Lampard tried to outscore the opponents. If we want to compete for titles we need to find at least one world class center back, without that you see that last year's champions Liverpool are fighting for the top 4 right now.

 
In back 4, CB will be a slight problem but under Lamp it was our attacker and midfielder that were more problematic defensively. 
I think if you go to a back 4 you need two decent defensive midfielders we only had one.

Seems to be a problem as we have decent CBs in a three yet big questions for playing as a back 4.

Though on the plus side now having Chilwell and James means one less to replace if we decide to go as a back 4. Yet if we did revert to a back 4 surely you would keep Zouma................

 
As far as I am aware Silva has signed a one year deal for next season. Tomori back from Milan would be interesting and Marc Guehi back from loan at Swansea we would have the personel to change to back 4 if needed. Guechi has played 41 games for Swansea this season and has been consistent. Rudiger is solid , Silva protected in the back 3 but would struggle in back 4 I think.

 
Our defense was beaten far too many times due to poor defending in the past season, even under Sarri we couldn't deal with simple crosses at times. That is all the fault of the defense, ours wasn't good enough.

An attacker can take a lot of attention and remove the pressure but you can't shield your defense for a full game. Take all big teams and it's basically us and Conte's team that plays with a back 3 on a regular basis, this is not a coincidence. We need better defenders in order to be able to change to a 4-2-3-1 or 4-3-3 and get a good result from it, right now with the players we have it's just too risky. Conte was very defensive and allowed the opposition to have possession, Sarri was very possession based with no risk passes in order to minimize the threat of our defense getting exposed and Lampard tried to outscore the opponents. If we want to compete for titles we need to find at least one world class center back, without that you see that last year's champions Liverpool are fighting for the top 4 right now.
We had Kepa under Sarri. You can put VVD + Terry + Maldini + Nesta at the back if your gk is kepa, there is nothing that you can do. 

Contrary to popular believe defending is not all about cb. If you analyze our defending under Lamp this season with back 4 our cb were fine. Most of our problem occurred because we pushed too many man forward and our attacker didn't trackback. 

Pool didn't suddenly turn bad because they lose VVD. They losed AL their cb. 

 
We had Kepa under Sarri. You can put VVD + Terry + Maldini + Nesta at the back if your gk is kepa, there is nothing that you can do. 

Contrary to popular believe defending is not all about cb. If you analyze our defending under Lamp this season with back 4 our cb were fine. Most of our problem occurred because we pushed too many man forward and our attacker didn't trackback. 

Pool didn't suddenly turn bad because they lose VVD. They losed AL their cb. 
Well I just don't see us challenging for any title with the current players in a back 4 formation. Feel free to disagree on that but for me part from T.Silva we don't have a world class CB and even T.Silva can't play a full PL season. 

 
I think if you go to a back 4 you need two decent defensive midfielders we only had one.

Seems to be a problem as we have decent CBs in a three yet big questions for playing as a back 4.

Though on the plus side now having Chilwell and James means one less to replace if we decide to go as a back 4. Yet if we did revert to a back 4 surely you would keep Zouma................
Yes, not having another dm was one of the biggest problem. When Kante pushed up and started hunting, we were too exposed plus our attacker did not track back. If you remembered under lamp we usually played 3 even 4 out of puli, Havertz, Ziyech, Werner. Tuchel fix this problem in very simple way he played only two out of of those 4.

 
Depending on how much we have to spend. Iheanacho could work well alongside Werner. Add Sancho to the mix and we could have some fluid actions across the squad.
Sancho is more of the same for me, his best position is AMR. Would he fit in to TT system and if so if we bought him who would we be offload. For me Gnabry is a better and has played only 19 games due to a muscle injury in February but still managed a goal more than Sancho recording the same ammount of assists in half the games. He is 25 years old and has more experienced playing for Bayern in CL and for Germany. Sancho hasn't exactly nailed down an England spot despite the hype. 

 
Well I just don't see us challenging for any title with the current players in a back 4 formation. Feel free to disagree on that but for me part from T.Silva we don't have a world class CB and even T.Silva can't play a full PL season. 
It really depend imo. But if by title you mean competing with city and pool, we need to improve in lots of area not just cb. 

With city and pool, you need to finish in high 90 to be even in contention. 

 
Our defense was beaten far too many times due to poor defending in the past season, even under Sarri we couldn't deal with simple crosses at times. That is all the fault of the defense, ours wasn't good enough.

An attacker can take a lot of attention and remove the pressure but you can't shield your defense for a full game. Take all big teams and it's basically us and Conte's team that plays with a back 3 on a regular basis, this is not a coincidence. We need better defenders in order to be able to change to a 4-2-3-1 or 4-3-3 and get a good result from it, right now with the players we have it's just too risky. Conte was very defensive and allowed the opposition to have possession, Sarri was very possession based with no risk passes in order to minimize the threat of our defense getting exposed and Lampard tried to outscore the opponents. If we want to compete for titles we need to find at least one world class center back, without that you see that last year's champions Liverpool are fighting for the top 4 right now.
Even one wc CB - albeit it'd help tremendously - has always the risk of an injury or else. Now Silva got injuried and Chrisensen stepped in - so good that one could almost forgot that Thiago wasn't playing. Zouma was probably the weakest of our CB but also he contributed when he had to play. Same with the signing of one worldclass striker IMO: if that'd mean we are forced to play a different formation I'd be very afraid of doing that since that's just too much dependend on one single player. I'd love one CB/DM hybrid player that could offer us a good deal of flexibility on the fly. Especially since I'm pretty convinced by now by James who I believe can play anything at the right side. Maybe, but that's a capital one, maybe Odoi can step up next saison and offer sth. as an alternative RWB - like he did at the start of Tuchel. That with Chilwell being comfortable within the formation could really help us playing against defensive lines as well as pushing forward on the counter.

There was a time I thought that Tuchel would most likely try to implement another system to let us create more threatening situations (around that Southampton game I think) but since then we've come a long way and although it always is a possibility with him I don't think he's doubting his system at all right now. It can get refined further and we already look very threatening. When Havertz finally finds some consistent form and Pulisic stays healthy we already look competitive without additional transfers - those could just be the icing on the cake and make us (finally) deadly.

 
Leipzig played 352/343 similar to how we play right now. 

We played Werner as  LF/LW in basic 4231 and 433 under lamp and it didn't work. You have to play something closer to 442 with werner. 
exactly and poulson and schtick played through the middle. Not sure what you are disagreeing with tbh, Its pretty obvious Werner has played from the left off a target man a lot of times, with success in his career. The main struggles for him as been as a lone front man or as an out and out winger, which I explained previous was not what was suggesting. 

 
Our CBs are not capable of playing in a back 4 part from T.Silva and it's still not clear if he's going to stay or not. Rudiger and Christensen are much more unreliable in a back 4 formation and Zouma can be insecure with the ball. If you ask me a new CB is a must if we ever want to switch to a 4-2-3-1 or 4-3-3, Chilwell/Alonso and James/Azpi can do the role for 1 more season but if T.Silva leaves in the summer we won't be able to play those formations and get away with it.
Bit of a sweeping statement. 

Lampard had a decent record at the start of the season barring 1 or 2 games with a back 4, sarri used some these centre backs in a back 4 and also had a decent record. 

When you look how we play now, we switch to a 4 at the back in game frequently. Now we are seeing James at right centre back, that is even more of an option. 

Thiago silva is staying for another season according to the media, I havent seen any reports to the contrary. 

The defence has been brilliant under Tuchel, but I wouldnt be suprised if we look to get an extra attacker in the team by switching to a 4 against the bottom half teams, where we have struggled to score goals. 

I think the aporoach to how we defend, the way we counter press, and the way we cover spaces to safe guard counter attacks,has had more of an effect on the improved defence, than simply changing formation. 

 
A back 4 would work alot better with a proper DM infront of them, instead of a slow deep laying playmaker. 4-1-2-3 formation, with a DM (Franck Kessie), CM/box to box midfielder (Kante, Kovacic) and CM/AM (Havertz,Mount).

 
Sancho is more of the same for me, his best position is AMR. Would he fit in to TT system and if so if we bought him who would we be offload. For me Gnabry is a better and has played only 19 games due to a muscle injury in February but still managed a goal more than Sancho recording the same ammount of assists in half the games. He is 25 years old and has more experienced playing for Bayern in CL and for Germany. Sancho hasn't exactly nailed down an England spot despite the hype. 
Trouble is we have zero chance of getting Gnabry, Sancho is on the market

 
Trouble is we have zero chance of getting Gnabry, Sancho is on the market
We come back to a risk/reward situation then as with Kane , is Sancho worth risking 100m on as he is unproven in Premiership made limited appearances in High stakes games? 

I think we a forget that all clubs have coaching staff who aren't there to just keep players fit or install players into systems. They are there to improve players we have and take them to the next level. TT Has installed the system it is up to his staff to train the players to play football. It always baffles me that all clubs invest time and money on players from 7 or 8 years old. Those that they deem to have good potential then progress to the u18 ,u21 & u23. Presumably these players are then coached the 1st team system , taught how to use both feet and generally improve as footballers. Surely with the ammount of players we have on the books we have players coming through that would be fine in the first team, if not its either poor decisions at 16/17 in keeping them or poor coaching. If a player gets to 18/19 having joined at 8 and isn't good enough to slot into the first team then something is failing along the way. 

 
With regard to coaching does anyone think Lampard may have done better with a different no 2. Someone with experience coaching in the premiership? 

 
Bit of a sweeping statement. 

Lampard had a decent record at the start of the season barring 1 or 2 games with a back 4, sarri used some these centre backs in a back 4 and also had a decent record. 

When you look how we play now, we switch to a 4 at the back in game frequently. Now we are seeing James at right centre back, that is even more of an option. 

Thiago silva is staying for another season according to the media, I havent seen any reports to the contrary. 

The defence has been brilliant under Tuchel, but I wouldnt be suprised if we look to get an extra attacker in the team by switching to a 4 against the bottom half teams, where we have struggled to score goals. 

I think the aporoach to how we defend, the way we counter press, and the way we cover spaces to safe guard counter attacks,has had more of an effect on the improved defence, than simply changing formation. 
You're right but how much would we lose in return defensively speaking with our current squad that clearly has more players suitable for a back 3 formation defensively speaking? 

Overall we conceded more goals under Lampard than under Sarri and one factor could very well be that we were playing a more open game. We were more direct and that resulted in our defense having to deal with more attacks and our defenders couldn't really deal with it, we conceded 54 goals in the PL last season, that's top 10 but we still finished top 4 despite it, the closest top 4 team to us had conceded 18 goals less than us.
During this season under Lampard we conceded around 23 goals in 19 games which is 4 goals less in comparison to 19/20's first 19 games so we conceded less goals and I wonder if those 4 can be a simple factor of having T.Silva in the lineup but despite that we had 3 points more last season and that was enough to be in the top 4 after 19 games.

When we really play a 4-2-3-1 again we won't have Chilwell and James playing as WBs, we will have Chilwell and James as LB/RB and Pulisic/Ziyech/CHO would be the wingers and that's really a different tactic from this one where our players can push forward without being punished for it, Chilwell and James and you can argue even Dave and Rudiger have been pushing forward and we don't get punished for it because we have at least 2 players covering for them, that simply won't happen in a 4-2-3-1, James goes too much forward or Rudiger tried to apply some pressure or to run with the ball and loses it and we're wide open for a counter attack, this has been an issue for Lampard because our LB/RB used to have this tendency to go too much forward and we used to get exposed. 

I'm just going to point out the obvious, Tuchel did improve us and we might look good in a different formation anyway but it's not secret that Liverpool is fighting for a top 4 finish because they don't have Van Dijk, that makes all the difference in the world from being champions to fighting for a top 4 spot and this is basically where we are as well and where we have been for the past few years since we didn't have a world class CB.
You can look at Pep as well, he bought for 50-60m Dias and Laporte and without them Man City would have been a much weaker team.

 
Back
Top