Arrivals 25/26:
Estêvão €34.00m: +2 Looks a big bargain. One of the most promising under 18 players in the world coming in on for a relatively cheap fee.
Kendry Páez €10.00m: +1.5 also looks like a bargain. Not at promising as Estêvão but very cheap for what he looks like he could be.
Arrivals 24/25:
Pedro Neto €60.00m: -1.5 I think we paid too much but I won't go so far as to call him a -2 yet
João Félix €52.00m: -1.5 This one is difficult as his value is higher as part of the Gallagher sale and he could end up recovering most of his fee on sale. Still looks like alot
Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall €35.40m: -2 You'd need to take 5million off the effective transfer keeping in mind that Micheal Golding went the other way for that amount and wasn't worth that. Still, this looks a rough deal and probably going to leave at a loss
Filip Jørgensen €24.50m: +1 Early to say but he looks a good young keeper and if given a real chance, i think could end up being a bargain
Mike Penders €20.00m: 0 I just can't determine either way yet. Aparently is very promising but you'd expect a bit for that kind of cash
Aarón Anselmino €16.50m: +0 too early for me to make a call
Mathis Amougou €15.00m +0 too early
Renato Veiga €14.00m +2 really good buy. If he leaves, it will be at a substantial profit and if not, we could have a good player
Caleb Wiley €10.10m +0 I just know nothing, I am would lean very slightly positive on Anselmino and very slightly negative on Wiley
Marc Guiu €6.00m +2 bargain. He probably won't make it at Chelsea but at that price, a really good purchase that will very likely end up making Chelsea money
Jadon Sancho loan but I think transfer will be around €30.00m: +2.5 absolute bargain, his current form and expectations might work against him, but to get him at such a low fee and reduced wages was great business
Arrivals 23/24:
Moisés Caicedo €116.00m: +0.5 Very good player, very expensive transfer fee, i'm leaning very slighly positive in the belief that he will be here a long time and contribute well even if he never gets that kind of fee in a sale.
Roméo Lavia €62.10m: -1 good player but expensive. Can't give him a positive rating unless he improves his injury record
Cole Palmer €47.00m: +3 one of the best players in the world, for a very reasonable fee and on a long contract at a tiny wage. Imagine the mess we'd be in without him
Axel Disasi €45.00m: -1 looks expensive, not a total flop but i can't see us selling him for his full incoming fee. Still Villa taking him at full wages +5 million could be an indication he might end up recovering most of his transfer fee
Nicolas Jackson €37.00m: +2.5 strong bargain. he's cheap and has a long contract meaning he will probably be here a long time at a cheap wage
Lesley Ugochukwu €27.00m -1 not looking great but cheap enough and young enough that things could turn around quickly for him
Robert Sánchez €23.00m -1 seperate the player (as first choice) from the deal and this isn't that bad. this probably going to end up leaving at a loss
Djordje Petrovic €16.00m +1 he's cheap, he's doing well at Strasborg, I think he's been treated a bit unfairly. I think he will end up leaving for more than he joined.
Deivid Washington €16.00m -1 haven't seen much of him and he's very unlikely to make it Chelsea. Likely ro recover most of his fee tho
Ângelo €15.00m +2 sold at a profit, maybe that's financial shenadigans, but a profit is a profit
Note: I think Christopher Nkunku for €60.00m was agreed before Stewart/Winstanley so I'm leaving him out of the calculation
Arrivals 22/23
Enzo Fernández €121.00m -1.5 I just don't see him ever recovering that kind of transfer fee even if he's a good player who could end up being very useful for a long time
Mykhaylo Mudryk €70.00m -2 I would have put minus 3 as an absolute disaster but his B sample hasn't come back yet and the club is still registering him for the Europa league suggesting they still think he has a chance of not being banned.
Benoît Badiashile €38.00m -0.5 I am largely neutral on this one. He's not that expensive and could end up being good but not shown enough yet so very slight negative score
Noni Madueke €35.00m - +1 I honestly don't really like him and don't think he'll make it. But i'm judging the deal not the player and the deal was a solid value/risk
Malo Gusto €30.00m +2 a good deal even very good deal. He will likely end up being sold for much more if he leaves
Cesare Casadei €14.86m -0.5 sold at a minor loss but with some add-ons. this looks like a very minor loss
Andrey Santos €12.50m +2.5 huge bargain for that price
David Datro Fofana €12.00m -0.5 was a cheap speculative signing that probably won't pay off but is likely to return most of his transfer outlay
Seems like my post sitrred up alot of comments, some constructive and some stupid and pointless
It was (obviously) just an analysis of the incomings and not the outgoings (which are also a very mixed bag) nor the squal utilization (bomb squad) issue is almost all negative.
If you want my overall feelings it's this:
1. I thought sacking Pochettino was a mistake. I think he's a better manager than Maresca. He's more adaptible with tactics, more resourceful in making use of the players around him, more experienced, better able to deal with difficult situations (like the one we are in right now). I think he's better at developing players overall (not just the few picked out that fit his tactical setup exactly like Maresca).
I don't think Maresca would have acheived 6th place (with an xG that would have seen us finish 5th) given that incredible and generationally bad injury crisis last season and I beleive had Pochettino stayed, we'd probably be doing a little bit better this season*.
*Off point/tangent a little, but sometimes I imagine an alternate history if Pochettino had his way and was still manager. We would have kept Gallagher and not bought Felix, which probably also flows through to not purchasing KDH and still having Micheal Golding (or selling him for a little less). Chilwell would probably be a major part of the squad, Chalobah (who was our best defender last year) probably wouldn't have been loaned out. We probably would have stuck with Stirling rather than loaning him out to a rival paying more than half his wages and then not bought Neto for €60.00m. With all that money we'd have saved not buying Neto or Felix, there probably would have been money left over for another striker (no idea who). Overall, I think we'd have a stronger squad and would be doing (at least a little) better this season. Anyways, back to main topic
2. The bomb squad is/was indefensible. First and least importantly, it is poor ethically and not becoming of a team like Chelsea. We are not some sunday league club that needs to f*ck players over like that in order to survive. But that's secondary to the fact it is just poor management to loan players out paying more than half their wages to play for a rival or worse (in the case of Chilwell), sit in the stands and do absolutely nothing for 6 months as one of the clubs higher earners. In the case of Stirling, we loan out the player and then spend €60.00m on Neto in what is largely a sideways move, just an incredible waste, It just a very poor utilisation of resources already at the club which then inevitably leads onto less resources available to strengthen the team later.
3. I will actually defend the recruitment strategy. When it works (getting Palmer, Jackson and the looking promising Estêvão Willian in young on cheap fees, cheap wages and very long contracts) it works brilliantly. In fact I think the places where it's failed worst is when we already have players at the club (sometimes on high wages that will be difficult to move) capable of doing the job (Stirling, Gallagher, Chilwell) or when we buy players (like Felix) when it's not even really clear that is the problem position that needs the resources the most (not cooperating with the team manager enough).
The issue with the strategy (or at least the way the sporting directors are doing it) is that it tries to do too much too soon. These footballers are human beings, when they move clubs they are moving to a new environment, usually moving house, sometimes moving country and occasionally even having to learn a new language. This harms team cohesion (at least in the short term) and when it's over done (like it has been), the new (usually young) players joining come into an environment lacking leaders and positive established team culture from senior pros.
I think back to an interview with Phil Giles, the director of football at Brentford (i think this is the interview linked below). As most of you will know Brentford (and Brighton) are probably the two biggest Premier League success stories over the last 5-10 years. Both clubs that probably belong in the Championship but through very good management have established themselves as top-half Premier League teams. In this interview he was asked what he/the team could have done better and his answer was (to paraphrase) "we tried to do too much, too early, and it slowed our progress". That is exactly what happened at Chelsea. New owners, tried to do too much, too early.
So overall, I am not happy with their choice of manager (I think we should have just stuck with Poch), the bomb squad was a big mistake and unnecessary and that was a sympton of them trying to change too much too soon. However, I think the recruitment strategy of young players on long, low wage contracts is a good idea if implemented more patiently and in better consultation with the manager of the day's need.