wallosh
First Team Regular
- Messages
- 2,035
- Reaction score
- 319
He isn't overrated, he is pure world classSee the overrating of De Gea is going on
He isn't overrated, he is pure world classSee the overrating of De Gea is going on
Sunderland are in a mess this season, yet Pickford when in goal always try to prove a point even there defence is bad."Last season was a shambles on his part"
You could say that about every one of our players bar Willian.
Doesn't suddenly make you a lesser player...doesn't with Diego, Hazard or the others and certainly doesn't with Tibo either.
I was referring to the Pickford comment and this is his only real season starting week in, week out. If you are going to use that comparison about the defence you might as well say Costa and Defoe are on the same level then as Defoe has scored a lot of goals with sh*t creativity around him. But no, of course they are not because Costa is at Chelsea for a reason. Pickford is a very good keeper but Courtois has proved for years now that he is a top goalie and he is still is a rookie for a keeper and already has won major trophies.Was anything he said untrue? (aside from the Pickford comment, however if Thibo has Sunderland's defense in front of him does he look so good?) Of course who he thinks is top 5 in the world is objective but don't you have to be performing consistently for an extended period of time to be considered there? He's a good keeper and all but if we're mentioning him in the same breath as Buffon and Neuer he must be great. He's had a couple great seasons in Madrid where they were competing for titles and one here when we won the title. Last season was a shambles on his part and I'm still not convinced his positioning and distribution are good enough to consider him better than Neuer, Navas, Buffon, Lloris and De Gea
I think it does. Are Diego, Hazard and others the best at their positions in your mind? If anything I think more of Willian as a player because he kept his head down and did his work when the going got tough. If Hazard has a gem of a season last year he'd get talked about as the 2nd or 3rd best winger in the world behind 1a Messi and 1b Ronaldo IMO. Sulking and putting in sub standard performances does precisely that, it makes them lesser players when compared to those who go on playing despite the rough time their team may be having. It doesn't change their talent level of course but talent isn't everything. The best in the world aren't where they are because they coast through matches and seasons falling back on their talent."Last season was a shambles on his part"
You could say that about every one of our players bar Willian.
Doesn't suddenly make you a lesser player...doesn't with Diego, Hazard or the others and certainly doesn't with Tibo either.
He is good and I think he deserves the praise he's getting with the way his teammates are putting everything on his shoulder. At least before their good run in the past two months.He isn't overrated, he is pure world class
When he has to face 6 shots a game, he's not so clever when he has only one or two things to do.He isn't overrated, he is pure world class
I think Tibo is the best all round goalkeeper in the premiership.Has anyone else noticed that when he makes saves, he doesn't push the ball back into the danger zone so much anymore ? He used to be terrible for doing this and it was one of my main criticisms of him. These days he is pushing the ball to the side or out for a corner. Anywhere is better than pushing it back into the middle of the penalty area.
These clubs can give us all of the money in the world for the likes of Courtois, Hazard and Costa, but we shouldn't take it. Courtois is finally starting to show why he was seen as one of the best in the world at Atletico Madrid. You can't replace that. The same goes for Hazard and Costa. Hazard's form has dipped in recent games but him and Costa are pretty much irreplaceable. Talent like Hazard doesn't come around often, and goalscorers like Costa are incredibly hard to find. We haven't had luck with strikers over the years, why would we want to put ourselves in the position where it could take us years to find another one ?He does everything with minimum fuss at moment, definitely cut out some of the unforced errors he had last year and earlier this season. Looking at the shots ( very few) he let in in the last 15 games, all pretty much unsavable. Then look at the ones he saved, he's definitely worth a number of points. It's ironic after Real lost their unbeaten streak, the next big news is they are going to sign Courtois. I suppose he's a wanted GK, but the timing is a bit suspicious. We should pay him all the gold he want to keep him. On paper, there are Gks like Butland, Hart or the kid from Milan to replace him, but in reality it will be hell of a task. Whoever comes in will be compared to Cech and Courtois every game, that's not a small shoe to fill.
Navas, yes! I even think Casillas is still better than him.seems I left out Courtois he's definitely top 5...Neuer, Buffon, Courtois, Lloris and De Gea...Navas is overrated