I think he's great. I'm not sure about the rose coloured glasses when it comes to Cech. His prime lasted perhaps 2 and a bit seasons? Tibo is in my view a better keeper than Cech was post injury. His dominance in the air is a massive factor for us.
These Madrid rumours are a bit of a stitchup. His kids live there. Naturally the city has a pull for him. But any time he says something like that all of a sudden it's Tibo issues come get me plea to Real Madrid. If he did want to go back to Madrid we'd be smart to offer a swap deal with Oblak for Atletico. Keeps him away from Real and means we get a quality replacement.
People like to make out that Cech wasn't the same goalkeeper when he returned from his head injury, but i think the complete opposite. In his early days, he was making De Gea like reflex saves, but as time went on, he didn't need to rely on that so much. He was still making great saves now and again to keep us in games, but his command of the area was the best i have ever seen from a goalkeeper in the Premier League. I also thought his positioning and where to push saved shots was better than any goalkeeper at the time. You would rarely see Cech beaten from long range thunderbolts because he positioned himself so well, and his one on one saves were excellent. He had a natural ability to push the ball away from the danger area too (something i still think Courtois isn't so great at)
Usually players are more fondly remembered as time goes on, but for some strange reason, Cech is going the opposite way. I don't know if it's to do with him joining Arsenal, but the Cech i remember was the most consistent goalkeeper around when he was with us.
I don't think Courtois is anywhere near Cech's level when he was with us. I think he is very good at coming for crosses, but i can't think of anything else he is exceptional at. I also think for the level he is playing at, he should be keeping us in games with some reflex saves. He supposed to be one of the best in the business, but i very rarely see him saving us. A lot of people say that a lot of the goals he let's in he could do nothing about, but that's the thing, the best find a way to keep some of these shots from going in. I have seen only one game this season where Courtois was making these types of saves, and that was against Arsenal in the League Cup. If we were defending for our lives like we were against Barcelona and Bayern Munich in 2012, i don't think we could count on Courtois to make those big game saves that Cech was making.
If i was to compare Cech and Courtois, Cech comes out on top on most things.
Reflex saves = Cech
Positioning = Cech
Dealing with the ball into the box from set pieces = Equal
Communication with defenders = Cech
Positioning of defenders = Cech
Dealing with long range shots = Cech
One on ones = Cech
Charging off line = Cech (Courtois is really poor at this, he's given away a few pens and conceded a lot of goals when he has come off his line)
Goal Kicks = Equal (they are both pretty bad at it)
Passing = Courtois
Penalty saves = Cech (no contest)
Saves at important times = Cech (again, it's no contest)
Performances in the big games = Cech