Argo
An Untouchable
- Messages
- 11,096
- Reaction score
- 10,706
So one admittedly awful game and all off a sudden Caballero's superior, this is worse than when Remy was rated on par/higher than Diego.At least Willy can keep his legs together...
So one admittedly awful game and all off a sudden Caballero's superior, this is worse than when Remy was rated on par/higher than Diego.At least Willy can keep his legs together...
You've written off a 19 year old already?You can't be serious? I mean people are getting annoyed by Courtois not making enough "for the camera saves" will quickly put that into perspective if we have Gianluigi "still be a prospect at 40" Donnaruma in goal.
As for Pope and Butland![]()
It’s not just one game though, he’s been poor most of the season.So one admittedly awful game and all off a sudden Caballero's superior, this is worse than when Remy was rated on par/higher than Diego.
You also can't be serious at your Donnaruma bashing, he's clearly a superb keeper at the age of 19 and can only improve.You can't be serious? I mean people are getting annoyed by Courtois not making enough "for the camera saves" will quickly put that into perspective if we have Gianluigi "still be a prospect at 40" Donnaruma in goal.
As for Pope and Butland![]()
That's harsh admittedly he has his weaknesses yet he has made some top saves, I 've seen that and I only normally watch the highlightsI cant remember the last time Teebo won us a game like DDG has for Utd. Even against clubs like Palace who beat us, their keeper was excellent in denying our comeback. Teebo seems to let every good shot in.
You've written off a 19 year old already?
Ten years ago i was asked similar questions about Walcott, i have never really got the hype with Donnaruma and i feel the older he gets the less "amazing" he will become.You also can't be serious at your Donnaruma bashing, he's clearly a superb keeper at the age of 19 and can only improve.
He hasn't been poor most of the season, furthermore if he let in Vardy's goal on Sunday he would have been burned.It’s not just one game though, he’s been poor most of the season.
If dropping him for Willy for a couple of games makes him buck his ideas up that’s a good thing right?
A goalkeepers career is much longer, how many good keepers do you get at the age of 19? David De Gea was one and look at him now. Walcott was always one dimensional even as a youngster, he had a crazy amount of pace and played for Arsenal, that was it. I see nothing one dimensional about Donnaruma.Ten years ago i was asked similar questions about Walcott, i have never really got the hype with Donnaruma and i feel the older he gets the less "amazing" he will become.
He hasn't been poor most of the season, furthermore if he let in Vardy's goal on Sunday he would have been burned.
Thibault Cortouis was one.A goalkeepers career is much longer, how many good keepers do you get at the age of 19? David De Gea was one and look at him now. Walcott was always one dimensional even as a youngster, he had a crazy amount of pace and played for Arsenal, that was it. I see nothing one dimensional about Donnaruma.
De Gea was on a different level at the same age. There's also keepers like Asenjo and Szchezny who were also suppose to be the next superstars. Also re Walcott, i lost count of the amount of times i had to argue against people who thought he was going to be a superstar and not just Arsenal fans.A goalkeepers career is much longer, how many good keepers do you get at the age of 19? David De Gea was one and look at him now. Walcott was always one dimensional even as a youngster, he had a crazy amount of pace and played for Arsenal, that was it. I see nothing one dimensional about Donnaruma.
The only good thing I'd say about him is that based on this season's performance his level is perhaps close to Courtois, statistically he's nowhere near Alisson or Oblak's level. Personally hope Real Madrid sign him, he'll be a good keeper but given the choice Courtois for me. Same as Pulisic, overhyped and overrated.You also can't be serious at your Donnaruma bashing, he's clearly a superb keeper at the age of 19 and can only improve.
And am I right to assume @Argo written him off at the claims we could be replacing him with Cech?Thibault Cortouis was one.
You don't rate Pulisic? I think he's quality.The only good thing I'd say about him is that based on this season's performance his level is perhaps close to Courtois, statistically he's nowhere near Alisson or Oblak's level. Personally hope Real Madrid sign him, he'll be a good keeper but given the choice Courtois for me. Same as Pulisic, overhyped and overrated.
That's fair enough, people overrate English youngsters all the time so I can definitely relate to you there. Szczesny wasn't playing at that age but he was a young keeper and looked promising, sometimes they reach their potential sometimes they don't. It's not wise to write off keepers at a young age, for me Courtois isn't that good and I thought he would be better.De Gea was on a different level at the same age. There's also keepers like Asenjo and Szchezny who were also suppose to be the next superstars. Also re Walcott, i lost count of the amount of times i had to argue against people who thought he was going to be a superstar and not just Arsenal fans.
I'm sure he'll be a good player but I think he's better off staying in the Bundesliga. For me he's a player who excels by taking advantage of situations, not creating situations for himself - imho that combined with his lack of physicality isn't a good combination for the Premier League.You don't rate Pulisic? I think he's quality.
I would love him here, I think he's gifted technically and has a lot of pace that could match up for the Premier League. I even think he could do well in the wingback role where Moses plays.I'm sure he'll be a good player but I think he's better off staying in the Bundesliga. For me he's a player who excels by taking advantage of situations, not creating situations for himself - imho that combined with his lack of physicality isn't a good combination for the Premier League.