Torres - The "Groundhog Day" Thread

Torres: stay or go?

  • Stay

    Votes: 34 15.2%
  • Go

    Votes: 190 84.8%

  • Total voters
    224
Consistent? Reliable?
Well it depends how much time frame you give him. He's played a whole season where he's been consistent and reliable.

It's only when players show capable of being able to do that over many seasons they can start being considered world class. 

Players like Bent are capable of having very good seasons, in which they are consistent and reliable, before fading to obscurity not long after. See, I believe doing the job for a whole season is showing consistency and reliability, doing it for season after season is when you break into world class.

 
Jose has said we are 2 clinical signings from being possibly the best team in the world. We know that means 1 clinical CM and 1 clinical striker. These will happen in the summer. Anything that happens this month is just a slight reinforcement for the squad, not a game-changer.

 
^ Pray it's not Rooney though, don't think I can stomach paying Utd around £20m & paying a 29yr old Rooney in excess of £250k weekly for 4yrs.

 
^ Pray it's not Rooney though, don't think I can stomach paying Utd around £20m & paying a 29yr old Rooney in excess of £250k weekly for 4yrs.
even despite  the fact he has been one of the best players in the prem this year? he's the reason united arent bottom half of the table

 
Jose has said we are 2 clinical signings from being possibly the best team in the world. We know that means 1 clinical CM and 1 clinical striker. These will happen in the summer. Anything that happens this month is just a slight reinforcement for the squad, not a game-changer.
Funny how most of here agreed this is the case and the club didn't do anything to fix it. Well they probably did but didn't succeed. World class CM and a world class striker. Striker case is a bit easier because we get Lukaku back summer and he is already one of the best strikers in the league playing for Everton at least.For the CM spot I really hope we could get DeRossi but it is probably very hard to lure him away from Roma. Backup options Khedira and Alonso who Jose knows well.

 
^What is motivating that though; is it a new manager?, being played closer to goal?, knowledge his contract is running out?, or could it be because it's a World Cup year?

I would argue its a combination of all the above factors, makes you wonder why Utd are not in a rush to renew his contract. Agree he is one of the best players in the league this year but he has this niggling injuries (he is injured again), and you can argue that will get worse as he gets older. Considering how we have been burnt with Torres, it would only make sense if we got the Man City route presently; where all their recent recruits are on low wages boosted with higher performance based bonuses.

 
I'd go all out to get Rooney, I'd love it if we landed him. He's an incredible player, he's put United as high as they are this season, let's face it. He's clearly still not 100% committed to United though, you can tell. He should have chosen to hand in a transfer request and come here last summer. I just don't think United will ever sell him to us though. He'll end up going abroad.

 
Jose has said we are 2 clinical signings from being possibly the best team in the world. We know that means 1 clinical CM and 1 clinical striker. These will happen in the summer. Anything that happens this month is just a slight reinforcement for the squad, not a game-changer.

I may be being obtuse here (unlike me, I know) but what does he mean by a "clinical" signing? 

 
Funny how most of here agreed this is the case and the club didn't do anything to fix it. Well they probably did but didn't succeed. World class CM and a world class striker. Striker case is a bit easier because we get Lukaku back summer and he is already one of the best strikers in the league playing for Everton at least.

For the CM spot I really hope we could get DeRossi but it is probably very hard to lure him away from Roma. Backup options Khedira and Alonso who Jose knows well.
De Rossi would be my dream player. Pogba would also be a dream signing because he's so young and already so damn good and dominant.

 
I'm not big on signing players over 30. Although Ballack was my fav Chelsea player of all time.

 
Specialist, consistent, super top quality. One of the best in the world at his position.

But that is emphatically not what clinical means.  Much as I love Jose, he can't just choose an English word at random and change its meaning!! 

There are plenty of very good adjectives that mean super top quality - but clinical is not one of them!

 
But that is emphatically not what clinical means.  Much as I love Jose, he can't just choose an English word at random and change its meaning!! 

There are plenty of very good adjectives that mean super top quality - but clinical is not one of them!
I took it as the signings must be "clinical" as in the perfect ones that will be the pieces that bring everything together, not the the actual players must be "clinical".

Still probably not the right words but thats the way I looked at it.

 
Well, clinical usually means objective, analytical. So if he meant his decisions would be made in a clinical manner, then that makes sense. Except that I'd have thought all his decisions would be.

I wonder if he maybe meant "critical"?

 
Well, clinical usually means objective, analytical. So if he meant his decisions would be made in a clinical manner, then that makes sense. Except that I'd have thought all his decisions would be.

I wonder if he maybe meant "critical"?
If he is using the word clinical, he is most likely referring to it's definition of efficient and unemotional. It may or may not have been the best word to use, but it technically works.

 
Well, clinical usually means objective, analytical. So if he meant his decisions would be made in a clinical manner, then that makes sense. Except that I'd have thought all his decisions would be.

I wonder if he maybe meant "critical"?
Actually in sports the word clinical means efficient, cool and composed under pressure, stemming from its medical origins as a word relating to surgeons and doctors, a profession with little margin for error and thus requiring highly elite skills.

Critical is not at all the word he was trying to use. Moi, is English your first language?

 
But that is emphatically not what clinical means. Much as I love Jose, he can't just choose an English word at random and change its meaning!!

There are plenty of very good adjectives that mean super top quality - but clinical is not one of them!
This from Wikipedia:

Clinical finisher

Clinical finishers are forwards that specialise in their accurate shooting ability, hence scoring goals. They are "clinical" in that they need few opportunities to score a goal being able to strike and place the ball exactly where it will beat the goalkeeper. They can be identified by their high shots to goals ratio. Clinical strikers usually play as centre forwards though other attacking players can often be said to be clinical finishers.

 
Didn't get much ball today, but battled hard against 3 bid defenders,took his goal with old skoil aplomb, I wanna see him played in like that more often, that goal I aint seen him score in cfc blue, thought it was a liverfool flashback, keep it up Nando!!

 
Back
Top