I used to drink with a son of Matthew Harding in the late 90s early 00s, lovely lad, id never slag MH off after all he was a fellow Chelsea fan, but my view is similier to yours mate, if i had his sort of wealth there's no way id LOAN the club money id give them it, it just doesnt seem right that a fan would make money out of the club, lets not forget he loaned us £6m i think it was for the MH stand, not exactly to strengthen the team, i could be way of the mark here but thats how i remember it.Regrettably, in many ways, have to agree with Carshalton's points re Uncle Ken.
In my view, our beloved CFC could have died without Ken's intervention (not something you could say about MH's financial input). Agreed, Ken made money, wasn't someone you wanted to dinner, had bad breath BUT he kept Chelsea alive AND at Stamford Bridge.
When MH came along (and I worked in the insurance market with him) the situation was not so dire. No one doubts that MH was blue to the core but he did love his populist image. If, as a director of a visiting club, you are invited to a boardroom, is it polite/clever to ignore dress codes and arrive in a players shirt and jeans? Would MH have worn the same to a business meeting in EC3? My information is that MH never GAVE Chelsea any money (in the sense that Jack Walker gave Blackburn millions). What MH did do was to lend Chelsea money (admittedly at possibly good terms for Chelsea) in order for the club to progress both on the pitch and off.
My points are:-
It was never as simple as Ken v Mathew.
We all owe a massive debt to Ken.
Whilst I miss Mathew hugely (and a very good mate of mine could have been on that chopper that awful night), he was a very shrewd businessman and his involvement was not as life and death as Ken's.
I know who we'd probably rather have a pint with in the Imperial but that's not the point!
Have to agree with that Mears left a mess (whether he totally caused it is another issue) Harding did donate the stand but Im sure if he had lived Chelsea had to pay it back in the form of a loan. Never met him so cant comment on what he was like but his arrival as a famous fan did coincide with the gentrification of football but he may have been there during the crap years, Bates is first of all a tight old sod who liked football but more so making money, He sorted Chelsea out and could easily have left it at that but went further by buying the ground and investing in the team at the right time. Then he made his wedge by selling to the russian.Mears nearly killed the club,and was happy to sell the bridge to do so.Bates took on the debts, saved the ground, and eventually sold to the russian fella.Harding RIP was never there when we were riddled with debt. Bit of a glory boy tbh.IMO Bates was very generous to name the north stand after Harding. Bates name would have been more fitting. So what if he made a bit of dosh out of it and left us with a sh*t hotel.He invested 20 years in the club and when he took over football and its fans had a very different profile.