nonotnowjim
Members AF
- Messages
- 7,902
- Reaction score
- 6,513
I do wonder why more players are not utilising the Webster ruling.We actually had plenty of first-team players that were sold for an actual or book profit (Oscar, Costa, Morata, Havertz, Salah, De Bruyne and so on).
A large proportion of our "losses" on transfers were because we kept players for their entire peak before moving them on, where arguably the club extracted a football value rather than a financial one from them.
Of course, people only remember the spectacular busts like Torres and Lukaku.
We were already doing this previously, it is nothing new. It will work some years and won't in others. The only reliable profit is always going to be from our academy.
The problems are:
- We're getting bailed out by Saudi, which is a unique circumstance. That will not always be an option for promising young players
- Our profits are mediocre rather than substantial. Angelo is a nice win, but none of the others mentioned will make substantial net profit because we paid a lot for them in the first place. However, the club seems less concerned with this than with ensuring a PSR/FFP book profit.
- Webster ruling: Players are free to buy themselves out of their contract after 3 years irrespective of contract length. While this rule is rarely exercised at present, that is largely because clubs offer short contracts and are often trying to negotiate the best sale value rather than keep the player. A player on a seven-year contract might feel very differently. Interestingly the Webster ruling also effectively caps the transfer fee to the remaining length of a player's contract, but a long contract fortunately offers some protection in this regard.
- We are known as a 'selling' club, so our standing in negotiations is already compromised to an extent. It seems like that might have backfired a little this year with no clubs seemingly interested in our players.
in our case I don’t think we have anyone who signed a contract more than 3 years ago.
But take Reece James . He signed a new 6 year deal in sep 2022, for approx £250k per week. This means in September 2025, he can buy out the remainder of his contract and leave us for £39m. (Remaining 156 weeks x £250k). Which if on form and fit is a relative bargain.
I wonder if it’s because if this starts happening, clubs will all lose so much money - and so they have an unspoken agreement not to encourage it.
I do recall a legal case with some club in Switzerland that appeared to balance the previous precedent set in the hearts case - but not entirely sure of the impact (Seems that the Swiss club who encouraged a player to buy out his contract from another club was fined and had a transfer ban - and there was also a ruling about calculation of compensation)
Last edited by a moderator: