Despite good intentions I never got to the cinemanto see 'Atonement' - good inetention because the book is superb. The only thinng that worried me a littlw about the film was how well they would be able to piece together the four distinct sections of the book. I guess the fact that it has been so well received means they managed it well - anyone who has seen it care to comment?
Well I have seen the movie and read about 80 pages of the book so I will give it a try.
I first read the book. Well, the first 80 pages or so anyway. But I didn't like it. Nothing happened. Well, okay, some things happened but not any major things. I just kept reading about the characters (which can be interesting) and about Brionys fantasies.
In the end I gave up. My mother too, though she gave up earlier.
I then thought that I wouldn't watch the movie. If I don't like the book then I would surely not like the movie, right?
Well I did see it in the end. Mostly because I do like Kiera Knightley and James McAvoy was great in "The Last King of Scotland". I also liked the trailer.
I was really surprised to see a movie that was...well...great. Great story, great acting, great music (won a Golden Globe for that too) and great cinematography (think it's called that).
The story jumps every know and then just like the book. For example, we see the fountain-scene from two angles.
The jumps works quite well. The movie makes it quite clear that it jumps so it's not very confusing for the slow-minded (will be interesting to see if my mom can handle it though
).
As for the different sections I'm not sure exactly what you mean, Loz, as I haven't read the entire book. But I think I can guess what you mean and I would then say that the movie handles it well.
I think the acting in the movie is superb. Knightley and McAvoy are great. Too bad they didn't win but I hadn't expected them to.
Two other actresses who should be mentioned is Saoirse Ronan who is just excellent as the young Briony and Romola Garai who plays the slightly older version of Briony and does it really well.
Garai, Ronan, Knightley and McAvoy makes this good movie into a great one. Them and Vanessa Redgrave who plays the oldest version of Briony. She's great too.
Finally I just have to say one thing. There's a war-scene in the movie that are just great. It goes on for about 5 minutes in one sweeping motion, without cuts or anything. Simply amazing and apparently it took some time to get right.