VAR in 2019/20

Everytime referee makes a decision, players will be all around him asking for VAR. Some referees won't be making the tough decisions at all, just wait for the VAR. I don't think it will help at all, in fact over use of TV replay just make people lose more faith in the referees and be grumpy about every decisions on the field.

 
I agree that even with replays the decisions are not always clear cut and because of the reason of turning it into a video replay freak show think it needs very careful implementation.

 
The technology is there but it still has to be used correctly.

FIFA got it spot on in the summer - very rare for them I must admit. However it seemed all the referees were very well prepared/trained to use it.

I'm convinced the officials will get better at using it the more it is used.

Looking forward to more decisions being correct next season...

 
The technology is there but it still has to be used correctly.

FIFA got it spot on in the summer - very rare for them I must admit. However it seemed all the referees were very well prepared/trained to use it.

I'm convinced the officials will get better at using it the more it is used.

Looking forward to more decisions being correct next season...
Have you not seen how poor the reffing is in the Premier League?

 
I've been watching the rugby internationals over the last few weekends and they seem to have it down fine.  Any contentious decision is referred, the crowd are shown exactly what the VAR ref is watching and the crowd can hear what both the VAR ref and the on-field ref are saying at all times.  No snideness or slyness, and it takes a matter of seconds, with the clock stopped, so they get the full amount of actual play.

I truly cannot see why any football fan would be against getting the correct decisions made most of the time.   Would be a pleasant change from how it is now.

 
VAR needs to be in the Prem. It will be a bumpy ride getting it set up. However, the end product will be better. I can't wait to see the blunders that happen with its implementation.

 
So was that not VAR last season then?
Only in the cups I think.......sure they made a meal out of it.......but a Club like ours should embrace it. Way too often we get jacked in games where our rivals dont. It can only be good news to us Chels fans.....imo.

 
I  think the main problem was it was way too slow and took momentum out of the game.
For sure....absolutely no reason to take so long. You are in doubt? Look at replays.....not conclusive? You play on as you were.

 
I've been watching the rugby internationals over the last few weekends and they seem to have it down fine.  Any contentious decision is referred, the crowd are shown exactly what the VAR ref is watching and the crowd can hear what both the VAR ref and the on-field ref are saying at all times.  No snideness or slyness, and it takes a matter of seconds, with the clock stopped, so they get the full amount of actual play.

I truly cannot see why any football fan would be against getting the correct decisions made most of the time.   Would be a pleasant change from how it is now.
I thought the FA were suppose to be getting advice from the RFU. Must be bad advice or they’re not listening to it. 

 
When VAR comes in clear rules need sorting out.  We've just experience two similar incidents handled completely differently in the Carabao Cup semi-final and final.

In the Semi-final:  Kane chases a ball, linesman flags for off-side, play continues, Kane goes down in clash with keeper.  VAR used to review which reverses off-side decision, and gives penalty.

In the final: Hazard chases a ball, linesman flags for off-side, play stopped despite Hazard being clear on goal. 

I'm not getting into which way either decision should have gone, but to me both 'off-side' decision were similar so I would have expected them to be treated the same way using VAR.  I am dubious about VAR, from watching matches on TV there are still so many decision that are not obvious despite numerous camera angles and even the pundits can't agree, it can only work if incidents are unambiguous and in those cases Ref's currently get most of them correct.  However, it is being introduced so we NEED consistency.

 
When VAR comes in clear rules need sorting out.  We've just experience two similar incidents handled completely differently in the Carabao Cup semi-final and final.

In the Semi-final:  Kane chases a ball, linesman flags for off-side, play continues, Kane goes down in clash with keeper.  VAR used to review which reverses off-side decision, and gives penalty.

In the final: Hazard chases a ball, linesman flags for off-side, play stopped despite Hazard being clear on goal. 

I'm not getting into which way either decision should have gone, but to me both 'off-side' decision were similar so I would have expected them to be treated the same way using VAR.  I am dubious about VAR, from watching matches on TV there are still so many decision that are not obvious despite numerous camera angles and even the pundits can't agree, it can only work if incidents are unambiguous and in those cases Ref's currently get most of them correct.  However, it is being introduced so we NEED consistency.
Id rather we just binned it completely. I dont care about decisions being wrong. I do care about celebrating a goal and then being told it wasnt a goal because someone was half a toe offside. 

 
The way it was used in the semi final should be the way it’s done but then that would have benefitted us in the final. Also our lot don’t like playing to the whistle, they like to stop and moan at the ref so that would be bad!

 
The way it was used in the semi final should be the way it’s done but then that would have benefitted us in the final. Also our lot don’t like playing to the whistle, they like to stop and moan at the ref so that would be bad!
I agree with this, don't think it applies just to us though. One of the fundamental basics of football is "play to the whistle", Spurs did, and we didn't and we got punished for it.

I think there needs to be a blanket approach for VAR and that if it is a close call the linesman give the attacker the benefit of the doubt and then if need be you can go back and give the offside and disallow the goal. I also think alot of teams defenders will be guilty of standing still with their arms raised appealing for an offside, whilst play goes on and the attacking team score. 

 
I agree with this, don't think it applies just to us though. One of the fundamental basics of football is "play to the whistle", Spurs did, and we didn't and we got punished for it.
I think Hazard stopped because the ref blew for the offside.

 
Id rather we just binned it completely. I dont care about decisions being wrong. I do care about celebrating a goal and then being told it wasnt a goal because someone was half a toe offside. 
A toe offside is not clear and obvious.

 
Back
Top